Slack Time Tracking vs a Standalone Time Tracker
There are two common ways to log work hours. You can track time inside a tool your team already lives in, like Slack, or you can open a dedicated time-tracking app that exists only for that job. Neither approach is universally better. This page compares tracking time in Slack with Tickin's /hellorimo command against using a separate standalone tracker, and it tries to be fair about where each one shines.
In short
Tracking time in Slack wins when your team already spends its day there, because clocking in and approving requests happen without a context switch and adoption tends to be higher. A standalone app wins when people want a dedicated, focused interface, or when the work does not revolve around Slack. Tickin lets you have it both ways: /hellorimo works inside Slack, and the same data is available in a browser and an optional desktop client.
| Track time in Slack (Tickin) | Standalone app | |
|---|---|---|
| Where you clock in | In Slack with /hellorimo (also browser or desktop) | A separate app or browser tab |
| Context switching | None; stays in the tool you already use | Requires opening another app |
| Adoption | High; it lives where the team already works | Depends on remembering to open it |
| Approvals & notifications | In Slack, with buttons and channel posts | Usually in the separate app or email |
| Works outside Slack | Yes, browser and optional desktop client | Yes, that is its home |
| Best for | Teams that live in Slack | Teams that prefer a dedicated interface |
Why tracking time in Slack helps adoption
The hardest part of any time-tracking rollout is getting people to actually do it, day after day. When clocking in means opening a separate app, it is easy to forget, and gaps in the record follow. Tracking time inside Slack removes that friction. With Tickin's /hellorimo command, employees clock in and out, take breaks, check their status, request leave, and confirm overtime without leaving the window they already have open. Managers approve requests with Slack buttons, and the team sees late-arrival alerts, channel notifications, and the daily Leave and WFH report where they are already looking. Because the tool lives where the team already works, the habit tends to stick.
When a standalone app is the better fit
A dedicated time-tracking app is not a worse choice; it is a different one. Some teams simply prefer a focused interface built only for time and attendance, with its own screens and its own rhythm. If your team does not center its day on Slack, or if certain people rarely open Slack at all, a standalone app meets them in a place that makes sense for them. A separate tool can also feel cleaner for people who want time tracking kept apart from chat. The tradeoff is that using it depends on remembering to open it, which is exactly the friction the in-Slack approach avoids.
Tickin also works outside Slack
This comparison is not strictly either or, because Tickin is not Slack only. Slack is one of several ways to clock in. The same account works in a browser, and there is an optional desktop client as well. So a team can lean on /hellorimo for the convenience of staying in one tool while still having a dedicated interface available for anyone who prefers it, or for moments when Slack is not open. The record is the same wherever you clock in, which means you get the adoption benefits of in-Slack tracking without giving up a standalone-style experience.
How to choose between the two approaches
Start with where your team actually spends its day. If Slack is already the hub, tracking time there is likely to earn higher, steadier adoption because it fits an existing habit. If your team prefers a dedicated space for time and attendance, or does not rely on Slack, a standalone interface may feel more natural. It is also worth thinking about approvals and notifications: keeping them in Slack means managers act on requests in the flow of their day, while a separate app centralizes them in one focused place. With Tickin you do not have to pick a lane permanently, since it offers Slack, browser, and desktop against the same data.
Explore Tickin features
Frequently asked questions
- Do I have to use Slack to track time with Tickin?
- No. Slack is one of several ways to clock in. You can also use a browser, and there is an optional desktop client. The same account and records are available across all of them.
- What can employees do from Slack with Tickin?
- Using the /hellorimo command, employees can clock in and out, take breaks, check their status, request leave, and confirm overtime, all without leaving Slack.
- How do approvals work when tracking time in Slack?
- Managers approve requests using Slack buttons. Channel notifications, late-arrival alerts, and the daily Leave and WFH report also appear in Slack, so the team acts on things where they already work.
- Is a standalone time tracker a bad choice?
- Not at all. A dedicated app suits teams that prefer a focused interface for time and attendance, or that do not center their day on Slack. The main tradeoff is that people have to remember to open a separate tool.
- Which approach gets better adoption?
- For teams that already live in Slack, tracking time there usually earns higher and steadier adoption because it removes the context switch. For teams that prefer a dedicated space, a standalone interface can feel more natural. Tickin supports both so you are not locked into one.